London’s woes weigh on Shaftesbury’s rents, dividends and share price


Ben Affleck is planning to direct ‘The Big Goodbye,’ a film based on a book about the making of the classic 1974 Roman Polanski and Jack Nicholson movie ‘Chinatown,’ but investors do not seem to be looking at Shaftesbury, the owner of large chunks of London’s Chinatown, with anything like the same degree of reverence or affection. Even though November’s £294 million fund raising buttresses the balance sheet and the real estate investment trust’s portfolio of assets is nigh-on impossible to replicate, the combination of the pandemic (as London moves into Tier 3), the UK’s uncertain economic outlook and ongoing questions over Brexit mean Shaftesbury’ shares trade at a 28% discount to their net asset value (NAV) of 743p.

That 743p a share figure is 24% lower than it was a year ago, thanks to drops in building valuations, net rental income and also the dilutive effect of the November raising, when Shaftesbury sold 75.8 million new shares at 400p apiece, to increase its share count by one quarter.

Source: Company accounts. Financial year to September.

Concerns are clearly lingering that office workers, consumers and tourists may not come back to Soho, Covent Garden, Fitzrovia, Carnaby and Chinatown in quite the same numbers, at least immediately, even if the vaccines do their stuff and beat off the virus.

Source: Company accounts

Shaftesbury’s rental income woes in the second half of its year, that ran from April to September, underscore those concerns. Just 53% of rents were collected in the six-month period, with the rest waived, deferred or outstanding. The commercial property landlord will therefore be wondering what will happen to the Government’s furlough scheme and business rates waivers and the impact upon tenants if they are not extended beyond March, should the virus still be making its presence felt.

Residential rent collection was strong at 83% and offices held up well at 79% of the total but then figures tailed off badly, with the receipt of just 54% of planned income from retail and 33% from food, drink and leisure sites. Net property income therefore fell 24%, hampered by £21.9 million of provisions for non-payment of rent and impairments.

Source: Company accounts. Financial year to September. Net property income adjusts for service charges, other expenses and charges for credit losses or impairments

A jump in the vacancy rate to 10.2% will not help soothe investors’ fears either and combination of unpaid rents and more empty buildings means Shaftesbury confirmed its September announcement that a final dividend would not be paid, in the wake of March’s cancellation of the interim.

Source: Company accounts. Financial year to September.

Yield is one of the major reasons why investors are attracted to commercial property and real estate investment trusts, so this is a big blow to shareholders and the investment case for the stock. Chief executive Brian Bickell notes that it is the company’s intention to restore dividend payments when circumstances permit and Shaftesbury does have two things in its favour, namely relative low debts and two very large shareholders. Capital & Counties and Norges own more than half of the shares between them, so their support will buy Shaftesbury time and the balance sheet offers breathing space, too.

Source: Company accounts. Financial year to September.

A net debt pile of £987 million for a loan-to-value ratio of 32% was pretty low by sector standards and Shaftesbury has since raised £294 million to take the loan-to-value ratio to just 22%. The earliest debt maturity is 2023 so again, that gives Shaftesbury time to plan and adapt as it waits for the return of commuters, shoppers and tourists (and its prime London sites would then be the third thing that the REIT has going for it).

The core shareholder base and low debt, plus its unique asset base, may help to explain why the shares do not trade at a bigger discount to NAV. That 28% gap between the share price and the stated asset value puts Shaftesbury in the middle of the REIT pack, with storage firms and warehousing plays still enjoying premium valuations and big, City-and-retail exposed firms suffering the biggest discounts.

  Share price premium / (discount) to last stated NAV
Safestore 55.7%
Big Yellow 40.2%
Primary Health Properties 41.4%
Londonmetric Property 27.7%
Unite 20.3%
SEGRO 25.6%
TRITAX Big Box 2.6%
LXI (2.8%)
St. Modwen (12.1%)
Derwent London (23.0%)
GCP Student Living (18.5%)
Helical (28.6%)
Great Portland Estates (19.9%)
Workspace (27.7%)
Harworth (32.7%)
Shaftesbury (28.9%)
CLS (36.4%)
Land Securities (36.0%)
British Land (30.9%)
RDI (45.0%)
Capital & Counties (42.2%)
Town Centre Securities (64.7%)
Newriver (52.2%)
Hammerson (90.4%)

Source: Company accounts

These articles are for information purposes only and are not a personal recommendation or advice.

russmould's picture
Written by:
Russ Mould

Russ Mould has 28 years' experience of the capital markets. He started at Scottish Equitable in 1991 as a fund manager and in 1993 he joined SG Warburg, now part of UBS investment bank, where he worked as equity analyst covering the technology sector for 12 years. Russ joined Shares in November 2005 as technology correspondent and became Editor of the magazine in July 2008. Following the acquisition of Shares' parent company, MSM Media by AJ Bell Group, he was appointed AJ Bell’s Investment Director in summer 2013.

Related content

Markets eerily quiet as pressures build and West End property firm Shaftesbury posts big loss

“Are we in the calm before the next storm? Equity markets were very quiet on Tuesday with little large cap corporate news to drive trading...

Tue, 15/12/2020 - 12:06

Shaftesbury swings to deep loss as pandemic hits rent, property valuations

London West End real estate investor Shaftesbury swung to a full-year loss after the pandemic hit rental income and prompted a steep downward revaluation of...

Tue, 15/12/2020 - 07:09

Shaftesbury raises £307m after completing £10m subscription component

London West End property investor Shaftesbury said it had raised £307 million from its planned share offer, having completed the £10 million subscription component.


Tue, 17/11/2020 - 07:28

Shaftesbury announces passing of founder and former chairman

London West End property developer Shaftesbury has announced the death of founder and former chairman Peter Levy following a short illness.

Levy and members of...

Mon, 16/11/2020 - 13:07

Unilever shines and Moneysupermarket update compares poorly

“The chances of a stimulus plan being approved in the US ahead of the Presidential election looks increasingly slim and this is putting pressure on...

Thu, 22/10/2020 - 09:57